Navigating the New Publishing Maze

"Do I need an editor?" "Is my book any good?" "Do I need an agent?" These have been the common questions of hopeful writers for generations. But these days, looking to navigate the ever-shifting landscape of publishing is far more complex. In this conversation, we pull back the curtain on what really happens behind the scenes in book publishing, and offer some honest insight and guidance about what authors need to succeed, regardless of whether they're publishing conventionally or going independent.

Most first-time writers don't understand that asking if their manuscript is "good" largely misses the point. The more important questions revolve around why you're writing and whether you have the fortitude to see it through. Quality can always be improved through editing and revision, but purpose and passion must come from within. We share why every writer—yes, even professional editors and agents like ourselves—needs editorial guidance, from developmental editing to proofreading, and all the way to publication.

We have over 50 years of combined experience in book publishing, which allows us to provide insights on finding the right editor for your work, determining if you're ready for literary representation, and building a platform that publishers will take seriously. We break down the economics of publishing, revealing that even a modest $5,000 advance represents a $25,000 investment from the publisher, helping you understand why agents and publishers must be selective. Whether you're pursuing traditional or independent publishing, this episode provides the education many authors skip but desperately need.

Want to publish successfully? Stop asking strangers to validate your work and start doing the research that will actually move your career forward. Check out resources like Reedsy for editors, the Christian Writers Market Guide for publishers, and join us next episode as we dive deeper into the publishing journey.